Find Your Perfect Policy: 866-843-5386
The Complete List of Auto Insurance Companies: From Allstate to USAA
Car insurance providers you can trust
Find The Right Insurance
Let our Perfect Policy Connectors do the work for you!
Which auto insurance company is right for you? You want a company you can trust, with reliable coverage that is also affordable.
We’ve rounded up the best auto insurance companies and given you the data you need for each. With our network of local agents, you can find the company that’s right for your vehicle.
Editor’s note (last updated November, 2024): We have updated this page with the latest market share data from private passenger insurance providers.
Auto Insurance Companies
Check out our articles on auto insurance and warranty providers’ customer service, pricing, auto insurance coverage options, and general reviews.
- 21st Century Auto Insurance Pricing
- 21st Century Auto Insurance Review
- AAA Auto Insurance Pricing
- AAA Auto Insurance Review
- AARP Auto Insurance Pricing
- AARP Auto Insurance Review
- Allstate Auto Insurance Pricing
- Allstate Auto Insurance Review
- Amica Auto Insurance Pricing
- Amica Auto Insurance Review
- Auto-Owners Auto Insurance Review
- Bristol West Auto Insurance Pricing
- Bristol West Auto Insurance Review
- Carchex Auto Warranty Review and Pricing
- CarShield Extended Auto Warranty Review and Pricing
- Clearcover Auto Insurance Pricing
- Clearcover Auto Insurance Review
- Concord Auto Insurance Review and Pricing
- Dairyland Auto Insurance Pricing
- Dairyland Auto Insurance Review
- Direct Auto Insurance Pricing
- Direct Auto Insurance Review
- Endurance Extended Auto Warranty Review and Pricing
- Erie Auto Insurance Pricing
- Erie Auto Insurance Review
- Esurance Auto Insurance Pricing
- Esurance Auto Insurance Review
- Farmers Auto Insurance Pricing
- Farmers Auto Insurance Review
- Foremost Auto Insurance Pricing
- Foremost Auto Insurance Review
- Gainsco Auto Insurance Pricing
- Gainsco Auto Insurance Review
- Geico Auto Insurance Pricing
- Geico Auto Insurance Review
- Geico DriveEasy Review
- Good2Go Auto Insurance Pricing
- Infinity Auto Insurance Pricing
- Infinity Auto Insurance Review
- Kemper Auto Insurance Pricing
- Lemonade Auto Insurance Pricing
- Liberty Mutual Auto Insurance Pricing
- Liberty Mutual RightTrack Review
- Mercury Auto Insurance Pricing
- Mercury Auto Insurance Review
- Metromile Auto Insurance Pricing
- Nationwide Auto Insurance Pricing
- Nationwide SmartRide Review
- Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance Pricing
- Plymouth Rock Auto Insurance Review
- Progressive Auto Insurance Pricing
- Progressive Auto Insurance Review
- Progressive Snapshot Review
- Protect My Car Auto Warranty Review
- Root Auto Insurance Pricing
- Root Auto Insurance Review
- Safeco Auto Insurance Pricing
- Safeco Auto Insurance Review
- State Farm Auto Insurance Pricing
- State Farm Auto Insurance Review
- State Farm Drive Safe & Save Review
- The General Auto Insurance Pricing
- The General Auto Insurance Review
- Toco Extended Auto Warranty Review and Pricing
- Travelers Auto Insurance Pricing
- Travelers Auto Insurance Review
- USAA Auto Insurance Pricing
- USAA Auto Insurance Review
- USAA SafePilot Review
The Biggest Car Insurance Companies
As of 2023, State Farm had the largest market share for private auto insurance, with about 18 percent of the U.S. market share. Berkshire Hathaway (which owns GEICO) and Progressive followed close behind at 15 percent and 12 percent, respectively.1,/
| Private auto insurance provider | Percent of U.S. market share in 2023 |
|---|---|
| State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance | 18% |
| Berkshire Hathaway Inc. | 15% |
| Progressive Corp. | 12% |
| Allstate Corp. | 10% |
| USAA Insurance Group | 6% |
| Liberty Mutual | 4% |
| Farmers Insurance Group of Companies | 4% |
| American Family Insurance Group | 2% |
| Travelers Companies Inc. | 2% |
| Nationwide Mutual Group | 2% |
A large market share doesn’t necessarily mean it’s the best insurance provider for you, so it’s important to evaluate each company on an individual basis.
Did You Know
Life changes like moving states can change the cost of your auto insurance because of differing state requirements and factors like road conditions, crime rates, and weather.2
Compare Auto Insurance Quotes
When it comes to auto insurance, shopping around and comparing quotes is essential for getting the lowest premiums.
FYI
Our free auto insurance quotes come from our network of over 3,000 local insurance agents.
Quotes can differ based on factors like these:
- Your driving record, like if you were involved in an at-fault accident with bodily injury
- Your driving habits
- Your credit score
- Whether you drive an Uber or Lyft, as it will require additional coverage
You can save money on car insurance coverage by bundling it with home insurance or life insurance using a multi-policy discount. Make sure to check what your personalized service will cost, what the claims service is like, and how the mobile app is rated on the Apple and Google Play stores. If you file a claim, how soon will you hear back? Does the provider cover your ZIP code? We can tell you all that and more.
Recap
There are hundreds of auto insurance companies in the U.S. To find the best company for you, shop around with at least three providers. To help you search, we’ve reviewed the best auto insurance providers on the market.
Citations
PROPERTY AND CASUALTY INSURANCE INDUSTRY 2023 TOP 25 GROUPS AND COMPANIES BY COUNTRYWIDE PREMIUM. National Association of Insurance Commissioners. (2024).
https://content.naic.org/sites/default/files/research-actuarial-property-casualty-market-share.pdf12 Life Milestones That Affect Your Auto Insurance Policy. Auto Insurance Specialists. (2021, Jan 13).
https://blog.aisinsurance.com/2021/01/13/life-changing-milestones-that-affect-auto-insurance-policy/